12 Feb Assisted suicide places most vulnerable at risk – The Orange County Register
February 12, 2015
By AARON KHERIATY and PAUL MCHUGH / Contributing Writers
In the wake of Brittany Maynard’s highly publicized death, many advocates are pressing for the legalization of physician-assisted suicide for patients in the throes of terminal illness, as in California’s recently introduced Senate Bill 128, a “death-with-dignity” measure. The claim to such a right raises many questions. For instance, if there is a “right to assisted suicide,” why would such a right be restricted only to those in the throes of terminal illness? What about the elderly person suffering a slow but nonterminal decline, or the young adult in the throes of depression, demoralization or despair?
Once we adopt the principle that assisted suicide is acceptable, then the fences erected around it – having six months to live, or having mental capacity, for example – are inevitably arbitrary.
These restrictions will eventually be abandoned, as the situation with assisted suicide in Belgium and the Netherlands demonstrates. In Belgium assisted suicide has been granted to a man with “untreatable depression” and to a prisoner suffering “psychological anguish.” In the Netherlands, assisted suicide has been granted to a woman because she did not want to live in a nursing home.
The debates on physician-assisted suicide have largely ignored what research in psychiatry and the social sciences has demonstrated about suicide. We know that suicide is typically an impulsive and ambivalent act. It requires not just suicidal intent, but easy access to means.
The No. 1 suicide “hot spot” in the world is the Golden Gate Bridge in San Francisco, where over 1,400 people have died. A journalist tracked down the handful of individuals who had survived the jump and asked them what was going through their mind during the four seconds when they were falling. Every one of them responded that they regretted the decision to jump, with one saying, “I realized that all the problems in my life that I thought were unsolvable were actually solvable – except for having just jumped.”
Suicidal individuals typically do not want to die, but want to escape what they perceive as intolerable suffering.
There are marvelous models for better palliative care and more effective care for the elderly, as described in Dr. Atul Gawande’s splendid new best-selling book, “Being Mortal.” When death becomes inevitable and further medical interventions become excessively burdensome, hospice and palliative care offer compassionate and medically sound alternatives to assisted suicide or euthanasia.
We know that the vast majority of suicides are associated with clinical depression or other treatable mental disorders. Alarmingly, less than 6 percent of the 752 individuals who have died by assisted suicide under Oregon’s law were referred for psychiatric evaluation prior to their death. This constitutes gross medical negligence. We also know that there is a “social contagion” aspect to suicide, which leads to copycat suicides – particularly for well-publicized cases portrayed by the media with romanticized overtones.
Some have called Maynard’s death “courageous” and “inspiring.” We worry that her death will indeed “inspire” others to follow her example. Many would like to believe that Maynard’s death was a purely private and personal affair, but given what we know about suicide’s social effects and the media portrayal around her death, we anticipate that her decision will influence other vulnerable individuals to choose likewise, whether or not they suffer from a terminal illness.
Suicide is the second leading cause of death among adolescents and young adults. It’s also the eleventh leading cause of death overall in the U.S. Not all suicides can be prevented, but many can. Social acceptance of physician-assisted suicide will undermine these efforts and place vulnerable individuals at risk.
Aaron Kheriaty, M.D., is an associate professor of psychiatry and director of the Program in Medical Ethics at UC Irvine School of Medicine. Paul McHugh, M.D., is a university distinguished professor of psychiatry at Johns Hopkins University.